Comparison
Side-by-Side Comparison
A clear view of where Tartan fits K-12 needs compared with GoldPhish.
Built For
TartanOnly K-12: districts, school boards, and independent, charter, and faith-based schools
GoldPhishBusinesses, sold mainly through MSP and MSSP partners. Its privacy policy says the platform isn't directed at anyone under 18
How You Buy
TartanPer school, with unlimited staff for districts and school boards. Prices for 1 to 10 schools are public, with 3-year and 5-year terms
GoldPhishPer user, per year. Premium lists $12.00 per user for 1 to 100 users. The default term is one year
Phishing Simulations
TartanTailored to the services your school uses, with AI-generated templates and adaptive difficulty
GoldPhishTemplates based on real brands and topics, sent to everyone, a department, or chosen people
Campaign Timing
TartanOne email per person on a 15, 30, 60, or 90-day cycle, at a random time
GoldPhishSend now, on a schedule, or at random times, using one template or random templates
After a Click
TartanMicro-training in under 30 seconds that shows how to avoid clicking next time
GoldPhishA remedial training page right away, a training email after the test ends, or no training, as the admin chooses
Training Content
Tartan60+ short videos written only for K-12 schools, each under 3 minutes and ending in a quick quiz
GoldPhishModules with assessments, micro-modules, and short animated videos, updated quarterly
Student Training
TartanStudent Phishing & Video Training for every grade, its own product with a price per school
GoldPhishNot listed on GoldPhish's site (as of Nov 2026)
Staff List
TartanSynced from Google Workspace or Microsoft 365
GoldPhishSynced from Google Workspace or Microsoft Azure AD (manual, daily, or weekly), or added by hand or CSV
Report Button
TartanTartan App Shield in Gmail and Outlook
GoldPhishMicrosoft's built-in Report button in Outlook. In Gmail, staff forward the email by hand to a mailbox you set up
Reported Emails
TartanReports go to Threat Manager for an AI risk score and summary, and you can move a threat to spam or delete it from every mailbox
GoldPhishIts practice emails are logged when reported. Forwarded emails are stored for automated review, then deleted
Gamification & Leaderboards
TartanPoints for training, quizzes, simulations, and threat reports, plus a shareable Cybersecurity Leaderboard.
GoldPhishStaff can earn recognition for correctly reporting practice emails
Google Workspace Security Audit
Tartan100+ automated checks for your Google Workspace configuration every week, plus 30+ guided manual checks, with a prioritized list of findings and recommended remediation steps.
GoldPhishNot listed on GoldPhish's site (as of Nov 2026)
Breach Notifications
TartanMonitors school email addresses and alerts admins when newly listed breaches affect staff, student, or shared accounts.
GoldPhishNot listed on GoldPhish's site (as of Nov 2026)
Comparison details can vary based on plan and configuration. Contact us for a tailored assessment.