Comparison
Side-by-Side Comparison
A clear view of where Tartan fits K-12 needs compared with Cofense.
Built For
TartanOnly K-12: districts, school boards, and independent, charter, and faith-based schools
CofenseEnterprise security teams. Its customer stories include Mayo Clinic, a defense firm, and a Fortune 500 manufacturer
How You Buy
TartanEach product sold on its own. Prices for 1 to 10 schools are public, with unlimited staff for districts and school boards
CofenseNo price published. Its site asks you to request a demo
Phishing Simulations
TartanTailored to the services your school uses, with adaptive difficulty. One email per person on a 15, 30, 60, or 90-day cycle, at a random time
CofenseBuilt from real phishing data, including smishing, vishing, and QR-code phishing, sent while staff are active in their inbox
Training Content
Tartan60+ short, school-friendly videos, each ending in a quick quiz
CofenseA content library for employees, updated as new threats appear
Student Training
TartanStudent Phishing & Video Training for every grade, K-12, priced per school with unlimited students
CofenseNo school or student training listed on its site (as of Nov 2026)
Report Button
TartanTartan App Shield in Gmail and Outlook; reports go to Threat Manager for review and triage
CofenseOne-click reporting that feeds its global intelligence network
Reported Emails
TartanThreat Manager gives each report an AI risk score and a summary, and alerts IT right away
CofensePhishing Remediation automates triage with expert-validated intelligence. Managed Phishing Defense adds Cofense analysts who run your abuse inbox
Who Removes Threats
TartanYour IT team, from every mailbox in one action, or a rule you set by report count and risk score
CofenseAutomated quarantine across inboxes, run by your security team or by Cofense analysts
Google Workspace
TartanStaff sync from Google Workspace, delivery straight to inboxes, and a Gmail report button
CofenseNot listed on its training page (as of Nov 2026)
Microsoft 365
TartanStaff sync from Microsoft 365 and an Outlook report button
CofenseCofense Reporter, an Outlook add-in for reporting suspicious email
Setup
TartanMost schools are set up in under 30 minutes, with free onboarding
CofenseSetup time not listed. Managed services can run the program for you
Gamification & Leaderboards
TartanPoints for training, quizzes, simulations, and threat reports, plus a shareable Cybersecurity Leaderboard.
CofenseLive action games among its training formats. No leaderboard listed (as of Nov 2026)
Google Workspace Security Audit
Tartan100+ automated checks for your Google Workspace configuration every week, plus 30+ guided manual checks, with a prioritized list of findings and recommended remediation steps.
CofenseNot listed (as of Nov 2026)
Breach Notifications
TartanMonitors school email addresses and alerts admins when newly listed breaches affect staff, student, or shared accounts.
CofenseNot listed (as of Nov 2026)
Comparison details can vary based on plan and configuration. Contact us for a tailored assessment.